Bringing you live news and features since 2006 

China Flag

Morningstar publishes report on tracking efficiency in Chinese equity ETFs


Morningstar Asia has published a report which examines the factors that influence the tracking efficiency of Chinese exchange-traded funds (ETFs).

The report, “On the Right Track: Measuring Tracking Efficiency in Chinese Equity ETFs”, is an extension of Morningstar’s February 2013 research paper about measuring tracking efficiency in European ETFs.
Authored by Morningstar’s global passive strategies research team, the report examines 33 ETFs listed in markets around the world that track the five major Chinese equity indices. Morningstar analysts used two metrics to evaluate the tracking efficiency of these funds:
·         Tracking error: the measure of volatility of a fund’s return in relation to its benchmark; and
·         Tracking difference: the difference between a fund’s actual return and the benchmark’s return over a specific period of time, on an annualised basis.
Jackie Choy, ETF strategist for Morningstar Asia, says: “In general, we found that both Chinese equity and emerging market equity ETFs demonstrate similar levels of tracking efficiency, albeit at inferior levels than their developed market counterparts. Our study shows that ETF providers need to continue improving the transparency and accuracy of disclosures around performance, so that investors can have the research and information they need to make more informed decisions. Better disclosure will help investors compare and evaluate ETFs through common tracking measures, such as those we’ve proposed in our report.”
Key highlights of the research report include:
·         Chinese equity ETFs and emerging market equity ETFs show similar levels of tracking error and tracking difference but are inferior to their developed-market counterparts;
·         Physical replication Chinese equity ETFs, which are ETFs that buy and sell the constituents of the benchmark index, adhere to their benchmarks with similar levels of tracking efficiency compared with physical replication ETFs that follow emerging market indices;
·         Synthetic replication Chinese equity ETFs, which are ETFs that use derivatives to deliver a similar return as the index, tend to have inferior tracking performance relative to synthetic replication ETFs that follow emerging markets indices;
·         Synthetic replication Chinese equity ETFs offer superior tracking error, but greater levels of tracking difference, compared with physical replication Chinese equity ETFs; and
·         Offshore Chinese equity ETFs have lower levels of tracking error and tracking difference compared with onshore Chinese equity ETFs.
“We’ve also observed that tracking error and tracking difference data points are extremely sensitive to minor changes in their inputs. As a result, investors should use accurate data in the calculations and exercise caution when interpreting the results,” Choy says. “Improved disclosure will further our ability to analyse these products and help investors vet these funds properly.”
The research report explores the tracking error, tracking difference, and estimated holding cost for both physical and synthetic replication ETFs by each of the five major indices: FTSE China 25, HSCEI, MSCI China, FTSE China A50, and CSI 300. 

Latest News

The August data from LSEG Lipper shows that the global ETF industry held USD10,547.4 billion in assets under management on..
HANetf has announced that their European Green Deal UCITS ETF (ticker: EUGD) has reached USD52 million (EUR49.9 million) in assets..
Legal & General Investment Management (LGIM) has announced the launch of the L&G Global Brands UCITS ETF. The firm writes..
Vienna Stock Exchange has launched three new thematic indices: CECE Reshoring, CECE Commodity Producers and CECE Clean Energy, writing that..

Related Articles

John Ciampaglia, Sprott Asset Management
Geo-political tensions and concerns about hitting clean energy targets have brought the focus back onto nuclear power in recent months,...
Nick King, Robeco
Europeam investment management giant Robeco has announced the appointment of Nick King as Head of Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs), in...
Kristof Gleich, Harbor Capital
Harbor Capital burst onto the ETF issuance world in 2021 and now has USD1.1 billion in assets in ETFs. But...
Europe’s thematic ETF provider, Rize ETF, has been acquired by ARK Invest LLC, the parent of ARK Investment Management LLC,...
Subscribe to the ETF Express newsletter

Subscribe for access to our weekly newsletter, newsletter archive, updates on the site and exclusive email content.

Marketing by