Bringing you live news and features since 2006 

Saker Nusseibeh

Hermes ESG survey finds it’s a long road to walk before real change occurs


The first in a four part series drawn from Hermes Investment Management’s second annual Responsible Capitalism survey, finds that while there is a growing awareness of environmental, social and governance (ESG) issues among institutional investors, the shift is not being reflecting within investment decision-making.

The survey of over 100 institutional investors into responsible capitalism revealed a watershed moment in how institutional investors are embracing ESG. Some 90 per cent of those surveyed believed fund managers should price in corporate governance risks as a core part of their investment analysis, alongside financial metrics. However, while investors are displaying a growing awareness that focussing purely on financial gains is not enough, the survey also shows a tendency to behave contrary to this.
Saker Nusseibeh, Chief Executive, Hermes Investment Management, (pictured) says: “The results are remarkable when you consider fifteen years ago ESG was considered to be ‘out-of-the-box’ thinking. It is clear that ESG has become mainstream.  However, the industry’s obsessive focus on measurement leads naturally to more short-term thinking and decisions that often miss the whole point of investment. This is to the detriment of the savers the industry is supposed to be serving.”
Hermes says that the survey shows the level of awareness around the importance of ESG issues is definitely growing. Some 79 per cent of respondents consider significant ESG risks with financial implications as sufficient reasons to reject an otherwise attractive investment. Meanwhile, 79 per cent of respondents consider significant ESG risks with financial implications as sufficient reasons to reject an otherwise attractive investment.
However, the survey found that reporting requirements such as IFRS17, the triennial valuation cycle and modern portfolio theory are driving pension schemes to think in short-term nominal returns, according to 44 per cent of the survey respondents.
The result, Nusseibeh says, is ‘siloisation’, where investors see problems in the context of a single duty, such as making sure there is cash flow available when it needs to be paid out, and doing that in the most cost effective way.
The survey also shows that 58 per cent of respondents believe the number of investment opportunities rejected by pension schemes because of ESG risks will increase only slightly over the next five years. Only 37 per cent believe institutions should place a greater emphasis on quality-of-life factors.
Nusseibeh says: “47 per cent of respondents continue to believe pension funds should focus exclusively on maximising retirement incomes rather than giving greater consideration to whether their current investments will improve or detract from the overall quality of life experienced by beneficiaries when they retire”.
Nusseibeh also pointed to the flow of assets into passive mandates as a headwind for the growing consideration of ESG issues by investment decision makers: “The opportunity for investors to effect change is quickly decreasing. By moving towards index-tracking strategies, investors are giving up their voting rights, and thus, their influence”.
This view is backed up by the report, with 61 per cent of respondents believing large shareholders are likely to ‘become unaware’ of the companies in which they invest.
Nusseibeh says: “Many investors appear comfortable with this because of their primary objective of beating an inflation target. Risk-centric approaches to ESG and the inevitable decline in engagement born of the shift to passive are both symptoms of the same failing – measuring performance by the wrong benchmark.”
Despite the growing awareness of ESG issues, Nusseibeh says there is a ‘long road to walk before we see real change’:
“Financial services need to address this and given the vital role that asset management plays in allocating the vast sums of savers’ money, it has a pivotal role to play in bringing about change in this regard. Today’s siloed and short-term investment approach is the antithesis of responsible capitalism. Change is necessary, if we are to ensure today’s savers and their children will be able to enjoy a fruitful world in the future,” Nusseibeh concludes.

Latest News

REX Shares has announced a strategic reorganisation that integrates its REX Shares, MicroSectors, and T-REX products, as well as REX..
Allspring Global Investments writes that as it builds an investment platform for the future, it has filed for exemptive relief..
LSEG Lipper writes that ETF promoters in Europe enjoyed estimated net inflows (+EUR25.1 billion) for May 2024...
The European Fund and Asset Management Association (EFAMA) has published its 2024 industry Fact Book, which includes a foreword by..

Related Articles

Marcus Wayerer, Franklin Templeton
Franklin Templeton says that emerging markets are navigating a tricky environment at the moment, due to factors such as the...
Matt Barry, Touchstone Investments
Back in 2022, Cincinnati, Ohio-based Touchstone Investments launched its first four ETFs, having previously been predominantly a mutual fund company....
CN Tower, Toronto
The winners were announced in the second ETF Express Canadian awards at the event held at The Quay in Toronto,...
Darren Jordan, Komainu
Custody specialist, Komainu, was launched in 2018 as a joint venture between Nomura, digital-asset investment manager, CoinShares and blockchain business,...
Subscribe to the ETF Express newsletter

Subscribe for access to our weekly newsletter, newsletter archive, updates on the site and exclusive email content.

Marketing by