A note from WisdomTree Europe research analyst Nick Leung examines how an investor might position using short, leveraged and Delta 1 oil ETPs.
Leung writes that investors holding a 3x leveraged oil ETP would have gained over 15 per cent in the first week of November—more than 3x the return of front-month oil futures over the same period. Underpinning this is an easing supply glut and a potential OPEC supply cut extension – both of which, we believe, reaffirm the structural bull case for oil.
“Ahead of the Vienna OPEC meeting on 30 November, we highlight how oil investors can express their views on oil using short and leveraged oil ETPs, and/or unleveraged oil ETCs.
“Oil is in backwardation for the first time since 2014. This is showcased by positive and near positive front future contract spreads for Brent and WTI respectively.
“Since the spread reflects the price differential between first and fourth month contracts, a positive spread indicates a backwardated futures curve, with further-out contracts less expensive than near-month contracts. Conversely, a negative spread implies a market in contango, with further-out contracts more expensive than near-month contracts.
“Since 2014, WTI has exhibited deeper contango relative to Brent. This is because WTI is the primary benchmark for US oil and it’s more sensitive to US shale production which has been in persistent oversupply in recent years. This oversupply created wider front contract spreads relative to Brent, and also widened the Brent-WTI price spread to USD7—the highest it’s been since 2015.
“Despite this, Brent’s and WTI’s improving fundamentals, evident by a 15 per cent fall in US oil inventories since their peak in mid-March, are driving both Brent and WTI to revert to backwardation. This is likely due to Russia and OPEC meeting production targets, with combined supply cuts of over 1.5 million barrels a day (bpd) easily offsetting the 1.1 million increase in daily non-OPEC production. Global oil production has contracted by 400,000 bpd year to date and continues to fall.
“Oil’s increasingly backwardated futures curve and recent price appreciation have not only vindicated OPEC’s decision to curb supply, but is now encouraging other oil producing nations to participate in supply cuts. Take Nigeria, for example. Having been exempt from the initial OPEC deal, it has offered its support to contribute to future cuts, potentially alongside non-OPEC members, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan.
“On a standalone basis, their contribution will do little to dampen global oil supply. However, this highlights oil producing nations’ increased willingness to tighten supply collectively to stave off the threat of shale and potentially drive oil prices higher. As such, the Vienna OPEC meeting on 30 November seems to be about not if cuts will be extended, but how long to extend cuts for. This presents oil trading opportunities.
“We expect to see elevated volatility in oil over the coming weeks as speculation over an OPEC deal extension intensifies. We therefore believe now could be ideal time for investors to consider for short and leveraged oil ETPs, which allows either bullish or bearish positions in oil. Investors may even consider playing the potential widening or narrowing of the WTI-Brent spread. Of equal significance is a leveraged ETP’s ability to improve capital efficiency. For example, a 3x leveraged oil ETP requires just a third of the capital required in an unleveraged position to achieve the same exposure.”