Bringing you live news and features since 2006 

Stop the tax on ETFs


Kirsten Wegner, CEO of the Modern Markets Initiative, writes that news from the US came earlier this year that the New York Stock Exchange is preparing to hand human traders a bigger role making markets for exchange traded funds (ETFs).

Here, we witnessed yet another milestone in the rapid ascent of these trading vehicles into mainstream American investing. Over the past decade, demand for ETFs has grown markedly as investors – both institutional and retail—increasingly turn to them as investment options.  In fact, the most popular ETF, the SPDR S&P 500 (SPY), routinely trades over 100 million shares a day.  According to the Investment Company Institute, share issuance of ETFs over the past decade has totaled USD2.1 trillion in equities, bonds, commodities and currencies. It’s been an exciting area of growth for retail investors, and an opportunity for investors to hedge their risk amongst a variety of assets in a basket by “theme.” 
There are many examples of types of ETFs, and many different investment strategies, but essentially many ETFs have offered a way for individual average investors to hedge the risk of investing in a single stock, and to invest across asset classes.
But overlooked in the current discussions of ETFs is legislation introduced by Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) and others that seeks to tax ETF transactions.
Recent proposals of the financial transaction tax (FTT), show that a 10-basis point FTT would actually have a 20 to 30-basis point impact on the ETF industry.  This is because the FTT would not just tax the underlying transaction and increase the ‘spread’ on the cost to buy and sell a stock but would also tax the underlying structure of the ETF.
In many cases, there is more than one transaction in order for a market maker to provide liquidity for an ETF.  The business model of an ETF often includes not just the transaction on the ETF, but also a hedge transaction on the underlying investments. 
In short, for a 10-bps retirement tax on cash equity transactions, one would expect that market makers would need to widen spreads in US equity ETFs by approximately 10-bps x 2 = 20-bps in order to cover the increased costs. The factor of 2 is driven by the tax being incurred both on the ETF transaction and the hedge in the basket of equities that the ETF tracks.
This means that the increased round-trip cost to a long-term investor wanting to trade a domestic equity ETF would be 30-bps (10-bps of their own transaction tax plus the 20-bps of wider bid-offer spread), assuming they purchased the ETF at the offer and then later sold at the bid.
While many in the political class in Washington are framing their FTT push as a revenue-generating movement that will only impact the wealthiest Americans and financial institutions, the truth is that they are misguided. The tax would have a staggeringly negative effect on the average investment portfolio.  At the end of the day, those bearing the cost of the FTT on ETFs would be mom and pop investors, pension funds, and other investors who rely on ETFs as a vehicle to advance their secure retirement while hedging the risk. 
Kirsten Wegner is the CEO of the Modern Markets Initiative, an education and advocacy organisation devoted to the role of technological innovation in creating the world’s best markets.

Latest News

Irish domiciled funds surpassed EUR4.3 trillion AuM (Assets under Management) at end-March 2024, a 15 per cent increase in net..
European white label ETF platform, HANetf, has announced its total assets under management (AUM) has now exceeded USD4.31 billion...
New research from European ETF provider Tabula Investment Management shows investors are expecting improvements in ESG from the gold mining..
As the ETF industry reaches a milestone of USD12.71 trillion in global assets, Brown Brothers Harriman writes that its 2024..

Related Articles

Dan Miller, IQ-EQ
With just over a week to go till T+1 settlement begins in North America, Canada and Mexico, time is of...
Emily Spurling, Nasdaq
Last October’s ETF Express US Awards 2023 found Nasdaq winning Best Index Provider – ESG ETFs and Best Index Provider...
Vinit Srivistava, MerQube
Index provider, MerQube, launched in 2019, with the aim of providing a “technology-driven answer to the most complex, rules-based investment...
Sean O' Hara
Pacer ETFs has announced the launch of three Cash Cows UCITS ETFs. The firm writes that this will give European...
Subscribe to the ETF Express newsletter

Subscribe for access to our weekly newsletter, newsletter archive, updates on the site and exclusive email content.

Marketing by