Bringing you live news and features since 2006 

UK flag

19 FCA SMCR investigations bring just one enforcement 


Research by global financial services regulatory consultancy Bovill finds that despite the FCA pursuing 19 investigations under the Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SMCR), to date there has been only one successful enforcement action.  

The findings come two and a half years after the regulation’s introduction, which aims to bring culpable senior individuals in financial services to account for misconduct. Bovill suggests that, despite the regulator’s desire to show the effectiveness of SMCR, punishments are proving difficult to enforce under the new rules.  

The Freedom of Information Request issued to the regulator reveals that 19 companies had been investigated. Of these, 10 investigations had been completed by the FCA, and nine firms remained under investigation. So far, just one individual, James Staley of Barclays Group, has been censured. The SMCR, introduced in March 2016, currently applies to banks, building societies, credit unions and insurers.

Ben Blackett Ord, chief executive officer at Bovill, says: “There is no doubt that, following the financial crisis, there was a need to increase the accountability in financial services to those who are in charge. And although the SMCR was meant to hold the feet of bosses to the fire, this appears far from easy.
“The reality of the SMCR is that it is always going to be difficult to attribute the actions of a large firm to a single individual. With a run rate of one enforcement in 10 completed investigations, we must conclude that senior managers are able to demonstrate that they are taking reasonable steps to control the businesses for which they are responsible. With the burden of proof firmly on the FCA to show wrongdoing, it appears that the hurdle may be too high. We’ll wait and see what happens with the nine ongoing investigations.”

In December this year, the reach of the SMCR will extend across all FCA regulated firms. This will mean the new rules will cover more individual senior managers, a large number of whom will work within small- and medium-sized financial services firms. This, Bovill believes, is where the regulator will land enforcement action.

Blackett Ord, says: “My sense is that we will see a higher frequency of enforcement action with small firms. This will have little to do with conduct but everything to do with the fact that it is likely to be easier to identify the decisions made in a smaller firm, than a larger one. Furthermore, smaller firms are likely to be less well prepared and less able to defend enforcement action.  

“We should remember that this all started with the financial crisis and the sense that senior managers of the largest financial institutions were being let off the hook. If the FCA’s punishments are weighted, even unwittingly, towards small firms then the regime as a whole will have been a failure.  

“Smaller companies need to take a leaf from the books of banks and insurers and make sure they are well prepared. It’s not enough to only adhere to good codes of conduct, smaller firms need to document and demonstrate it too.”

Latest News

BlackRock's iShares, an undisputed leader among European ETF issuers, pushed further ahead in Q1 with EUR173 billion in trades, triple..
European ETFs raised USD47.8 billion in Q1, a 15 per cent increase compared to the same period in 2023, according..
LSEG Lipper’s March report finds that globally equity ETFs (+EUR113.2 billion) enjoyed the highest estimated net inflows for the month,..
Morningstar has published a review of the European ETF market for the first quarter 2024, which finds that it gathered..

Related Articles

etf active trading
Latest Morningstar data shows actively managed ETFs’ share of the US ETF market rose to 8.5 per cent at the...
Kristen Mierzwa, FTSE Russell
Index Investments Group (IIG), a division within index provider FTSE Russell, has extended its range of indices through two new...
US ETF issuers of active ETFs are facing an increase in fees from the big custodian firms, such as Charles...
Taylor Krystkowiak, Themes ETFs
Themes ETFs opened its doors in December 2023, with an introductory suite of 11 ETFs – seven thematic and four...
Subscribe to the ETF Express newsletter

Subscribe for access to our weekly newsletter, newsletter archive, updates on the site and exclusive email content.

Marketing by