Bringing you live news and features since 2006 

Scope Analysis reveals multi-asset direct funds outperform funds of funds over a 10-year period


Multi-asset funds that invest directly in securities achieved better average performance than funds of funds over a 10-year period, according to recent research conducted by Scope Analysis.

Scope, which specialises in the analysis and rating of asset management companies, mutual funds and alternative investment funds,  evaluated the performance of more than 800 multi-asset funds – balanced, dynamic, flexible and conservative – with a track record of at least 10 years, all of which invest globally and are licensed for sale in Germany and other countries.

The study found that in all the above four peer groups, the biggest difference in performance between direct funds and funds of funds was recorded in the ‘global balanced’ category where the nearly 100 direct funds achieved an average annual return of 5.5 per cent. The 71 funds of funds in this peer group recorded an average return of only 4.6 per cent.
The report found that there was little to distinguish the performance of direct funds and funds of funds in the ‘global dynamic’ category where both averaged a return of 6.6 per cent over the past 10 years. This was also the best performance of the multi-asset funds surveyed.
However, the research found that for funds of funds managers, even if they under-perform traditional direct funds on average, those funds of funds that perform well do tend to perform better than direct funds.
Martin Fechtner, head of fund analysis at Scope, points out that funds with a top rating usually outperformed rivals in the same category significantly and in three of the four comparison groups considered, the top rating ratio of funds of funds was higher than that of direct funds adding that the Scope fund rating always reflects performance and risk aspects.
“One major advantage that might explain the outperformance of the best performing funds of funds is that they can pick the best performing funds in separate asset classes. A very good fund picker can create a superior portfolio,” he explains.   
In terms of volatility, the differences between funds of funds and direct funds were found to be comparatively low. In the balanced and dynamic compared with flexible and conservative categories, they turned out to have nearly similar or reduced volatility. Only in the ‘global conservative’ category – which comprises multi-assets funds or funds of funds with low risk profiles – did funds of funds show noticeably lower volatility at an average of 3.5 per cent compared with 4.4 per cent for direct funds.
The survey found that only in the ‘global conservative’ category were funds of funds significantly less volatile (maximum loss: funds of funds with -4.6 per cent on average, direct funds with -6 per cent).
It is to be expected that funds of funds perform less well because of the extra costs involved, explains Fechtner. “But what is more surprising is that despite broader diversification, they offer hardly any significant advantages from being less volatile. One explanation might be that, as a rule, direct funds already have broadly diversified portfolios so further diversification through the funds of funds approach adds little extra benefit.”

Latest News

BlackRock’s global ETP flows report for June finds a steady rise with USD128.1 billion added to global ETPs in June,..
Morningstar’s global ETF flows report for the first half of 2024 shows that actively managed ETFs have captured 25 per..
The surge in bitcoin ETF launches and funds flowing into the sector is transforming institutional investment in digital assets but..
LSEG Lipper’s latest research finds that the majority of actively managed funds and ETFs globally were not able to beat..

Related Articles

Chris Lo, Columbia Threadneedle
In a recent insight on India by Columbia Threadneedle Investments, the firm reports that the country’s economic reforms, which aim...
With an election on the horizon in the United States a group of ETFs is poised to capture investments on...
Robot worker
Qraft Technologies, based in South Korea, specialises in the use of AI in security selection and portfolio construction....
Andrea Busi, Directa SIM
Romain Thomas talks to Andrea Busi (pictured), CEO of Directa SIM, who explains why the online trading platform has just...
Subscribe to the ETF Express newsletter

Subscribe for access to our weekly newsletter, newsletter archive, updates on the site and exclusive email content.

Marketing by