Bringing you live news and features since 2006 

CFA survey finds European investment professionals believe banning inducements unlikely to prevent mis-selling


As the European Union considers a ban on inducement payments, a new survey released by CFA Institute, the global association of investment professionals, finds that a majority of investment professionals think a ban is unlikely to prevent mis-selling of investment products.

The survey, CFA Institute Global Survey on Inducements, which garnered responses from more than 1,000 investment professionals worldwide, sought to examine views concerning possible regulations to restrict the practice of inducement payments on the sale of certain investment products.

Just a third (34 per cent) of investment professionals surveyed in the EU think that inducement payments should be banned, with respondents citing concerns that this could negatively impact on the variety of products offered to clients. This compares to almost half (48 per cent) of respondents in the UK, where inducements are already banned.

As opposed to an outright ban, investment professionals in the EU instead favoured increasing efforts on financial literacy and investor education (59 per cent) and mandating clear disclosure of all commission payments received by distributors before investments are made (55 per cent) as more effective methods of preventing mis-selling.

Josina Kamerling, Head of Regulatory Outreach for CFA Institute in EMEA, says: “Policymakers in the EU are actively discussing whether to restrict the practice of inducements on the sale of specific investment products. This important debate is often caught between the risks inherent in the current system for biased, costly, and unsuitable investment advice on the one hand, and on the other, the concerns about a growing advice gap as a potential consequence of an inducements ban. However, diverging views amongst EU member states is likely to prevent a unified approach on the issue, and is reflective of the diversity of market structures which needs to be tackled before any ban. In our view, banning inducements is not the immediate solution, but addressing a number of key market structure issues is crucial.”

“There are measures that we believe regulators can take to tackle the underlying incentivisation issues behind product mis-selling without resorting to an inducements ban, which carries risks of its own. Our survey finds that the most important regulatory reforms needed to combat mis-selling are to mandate clearer and full disclosures of commissions and fees paid, and to introduce clear standards for product information including cost structures. Such a move would help bring the standards at play in the practice of inducements into line with what is already in place for investment performance information.”

Other key findings from the survey include:

·         Globally, just 33 per cent of respondents believe commission payments to financial advisers in respect of retail financial products should be banned and 45 per cent agree that a total ban could negatively impact on the variety of products offered to clients.

·         Most respondents (65 per cent) consider remuneration structures currently in place at distributors to be the main cause of mis-selling practices. This figure rises to 67 per cent within the EU, and 73 per cent in the UK.

·         Most respondents agree that the most important reform needed to combat mis-selling would be to mandate disclosure of all commission payments received by distributors before investments are made (66 per cent). This was felt most keenly in the UK, with 78 per cent of respondents in favour. Further, 65 per cent of respondents globally felt that improving disclosures of product key features, including full disclosure of all product costs would be an important mandate (UK 68 per cent).

·         Globally, 81 per cent of respondents agree that a full disclosure requirement (with appropriate enforcement) on all commissions and fees paid could be helpful to combat the issues of mis-selling of financial products.

·         Increasing efforts on financial literacy and investor education also ranked highly in most markets as an important reform (46 per cent). (EU 59 per cent, UK 55 per cent)

·         Globally, 45 per cent of respondents believe product choice for customers would likely diminish if inducements are banned, with distributors no longer offering some products, such as those from third parties.

·         Globally, 30 per cent of respondents felt that an inducements ban may result in retail investors steering away from advisers and advice channels in favour of self-directed, execution-only, or retail brokerage investment platforms. (EU 33 per cent, UK 36 per cent)

·         Most respondents (71 per cent) agree that strengthening investor education before any regulatory moves associated with mis-selling is necessary for any new regulation to be a success.

Latest News

Digital asset manager CoinShares International Limited has announced the launch of its hedge fund division, CoinShares Hedge Fund Solutions...
Despite a small contraction in assets caused by a complex market and macroeconomic scenario in Europe and at the global..
State Street Global Advisors, the asset management business of State Street Corporation, has published the results of its Gold ETF..
HANetf has announced that Sprott Uranium Miners UCITS ETF (URNM) has reached USD108.18 million AUM for the first time since..

Related Articles

Kristof Gleich, Harbor Capital
Harbor Capital burst onto the ETF issuance world in 2021 and now has USD1.1 billion in assets in ETFs. But...
Europe’s thematic ETF provider, Rize ETF, has been acquired by ARK Invest LLC, the parent of ARK Investment Management LLC,...
Jeff Ringdahl, Resolute Investment Management
End of August saw the launch of alternatives firm Man Group’s first ETF, using its AHL systematic trading system to...
Arne Noack, DWS
July saw the launch of DWS Group’s Xtrackers US Green Infrastructure Select Equity ETF (NASDAQ: UPGR) designed to offer both...
Subscribe to the ETF Express newsletter

Subscribe for access to our weekly newsletter, newsletter archive, updates on the site and exclusive email content.

Marketing by